Hunter orders a margarita pizza but receives a marinara pizza instead, which infuriates him due to his seafood allergy. He threatens to call the pizzeria owner, an acquaintance, to get the delivery guy, Guy, fired. Desperate, Guy offers to make the correct pizza and clean Hunter's apartment. Pressed for time, Guy calls his girlfriend, Girl, to assist. While Guy cooks, Hunter humiliates and has sex with Girl, who believes she must comply with Hunter's demands. Guy and the pizza arrive too late to prevent the encounter. Ironically, Hunter ends up disliking the new pizza.